Selling Your Jewelry

Looking for a jewelry buyer? 
 Come to Belmar Jewelers for expert evaluations of your gold and silver jewelry, diamond jewelry, watches and coins in a relaxed environment with no obligation.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • How many items can I bring?

    You may bring as many pieces of jewelry, watches, silver and coins that you like. 

  • What types of things can I bring to sell? What if I don't know if it's real or costume?

    Bring all of your jewelry pieces that you'd like evaluated and our appraiser will sort the fine jewelry from the costume for you. The appraiser will evaluate your fine jewelry (gold, diamonds, gemstones, silver), watches, coins and sterling silver items such as place settings.

  • I'm not sure if I want to sell my pieces. Is that okay?

    If you are unsure about selling your jewelry that's fine.  The appraiser will evaluate your items and discuss their value with you. Of course the evaluation is free and there is no obligation to sell your items.

Shop Our Estate Collection

We specialize in all kinds of jewelry from pre-owned contemporary and modern jewelry to antique jewelry, designer pieces, engagement rings, wedding bands and more.  Not only do we carry diamond jewelry, we also have a great selection of gemstone jewelry such as with emeralds, rubies and sapphires.  Find the perfect piece today.  In addition to our storefront on Main Street in Belmar, NJ you can browse and make purchases on-line at our Etsy and Shopify shops.

Knowledgeable Service

Our founder, Joe Carl, appreciates the craftsmanship in antique and vintage pieces and started collecting when he was a teenager. Joe is an expert in identifying the age, history and specifics of jewelry items, and has been a consultant to many jewelers and antique dealers over the years. Let Joe and his experienced staff assist you in locating just the right piece.

Full-Service Jewelry Store

  • In addition to offering a fine selection of estate jewelry for sale, we offer new jewelry.  All at very reasonable prices.   
  • We buy gold and silver jewelry and repair fine jewelry and watches. 
  • Roadshow style jewelry appraisals and insurance appraisals.  
  • Free gift wrap service.

We buy and sell jewelry in Belmar, NJ.  
Visit us for great deals on preowned and estate jewelry!